Swap of
airwaves encounters snags
By Paul Davidson, USA TODAY (1/16/06)
A long-awaited swap of airwaves aimed at eliminating
cellphone interference with emergency-service radios across the USA is in
turmoil, prolonging communications problems and risking public safety, law
enforcement officials say.
Public-safety officials and
consultants largely blame cost disputes with Sprint Nextel, which is bankrolling
the $2.8 billion project. They fear the spectrum transfer, which began in July and
is to be completed by mid-2008, could be delayed or done improperly, further
hindering communications.
Sprint Nextel says the disputes
were to be expected.
"We have significant concerns that
the process has been stalled," says Robert Gurss of the Association of
Public-Safety Communications Officials, which last week voiced its concerns to the
Federal Communications Commission. "Interference could endanger lives."
Since the mid-1990s, Nextel
cellphones have disrupted public-safety radio systems in hundreds of cities,
including Seattle, Miami and Denver. The reason: Frequencies used by public safety
and Nextel are interlaced. The problem sometimes hampers emergency response, such
as when firefighters at a 2004 Elks Lodge blaze in Mesquite, Texas, could not use
their walkie-talkies.
That year, the FCC approved a plan
to move Nextel and public safety to separate blocks of spectrum. Sprint Nextel,
which acquired Nextel last year, will get prime airwaves valued at $4.8 billion.
In exchange, it must give up airwaves worth $2 billion and pay for retuning
radios, estimated to cost $2.8 billion. But if retuning costs more, Sprint Nextel
must pay up, even if it loses money.
That caveat has prompted the
company to dispute nearly all of the dozens of funding requests public-safety
agencies have made and to not even respond to many of them, say emergency
responders and their biggest adviser, RCC Consultants. Unresolved feuds are being
reviewed by a mediator whose decision can be appealed to the FCC.
Sprint Nextel "is arguing over
every cent," says RCC chief Mike Hunter. For instance, he says, the company
disputed the $14,000 that Manasass, Va., schools seek to retune radios for their
buses, saying $8,000 should be sufficient.
Sprint Nextel denies pinching
pennies. "We are committed to spend whatever it takes" but want to "make sure
costs are appropriate," says company executive Geoffrey Stearn.
Public-safety agencies and RCC
also assail the project's managers, led by BearingPoint. Despite netting more than
$20 million in fees so far, the managers haven't closely monitored negotiations or
prodded Sprint Nextel to be more responsive, they say.
BearingPoint's Brett Haan, who's
overseeing the swap, said the managers "take the concerns of public safety very
seriously" and are working "to make sure the (project) is fast, fair and
efficient."
The FCC is "looking into these
issues," said spokesman David Fiske.