Editor and Publisher, one of the most respected publications in all of journalism, is examining the firing of Kansas City Star columnist Steve Penn, sources have told Bottom Line Communications exclusively.
Allan Wolper, an award-winning journalist and professor at Rutgers University and radio host, is writing a piece about the Penn situation for his column, “Ethics Corner,” scheduled to appear in September.
Was Penn’s firing justified? There are many aspects of the story Wolper will be analyzing.
Penn, who joined the Star in 1980, was fired last July for using material from press releases in his columns. Editors said they found repurposed prose in “more than a dozen examples in Penn’s columns dating back to 2008.”
In July Penn filed suit against McClatchy Newspapers, the Star’s owner, asking for $25,000 plus punitive damages.
In his complaint, Penn, who joined the paper in 1980, says “the widespread practice in journalism is to treat such releases as having been voluntarily released by their authors into the flow of news with the intention that the release will be reprinted or republished, and preferably with no or minimal editing.”
Wolper has won over 50 awards, including, television’s prestigious Alfred I. duPont/Columbia University Award – the Pulitzer Prize of broadcast news. He won the National Headliner Award for his radio commentaries, and has been honored by The Medill Graduate School of Journalism at Northwestern University, The Pennsylvania State University, the New York Chapter of Society of Professional Journalists and the National Press Club for his ethics columns in Editor and Publisher Magazine.











SHOULD BE INTERESTING
I await Mr. Wolper’s piece and, of course, I await the outcome of this civil case against McClatchy. Should be interesting.
AWFUL COLUMNIST
Of course, journalists are expected to use and run news releases. That’s their purpose. That said, Penn was an awful and boring columnist who should have been fired long ago for being irrelevant.
ELIMINATE THE MIDDLEMAN!!
All journalist are lazy sometimes. We reuse copy from a new release to fill space or time. It’s used when it comes to telling people what time an event is or what day it is and a number or website to get in contact with the event.
We shouldn’t be lazy all the time and let the press release be the story we air or publish and put our names to it. Why have a reporter? Just eliminate the middle person and charge the flack for the space. Two-thumbs up for the Star(okay a bit of plagiarism with the two thumbs up)
I know you were being sarcastic, but the KC Star does exactly that with its business promotions. It charges companies for the announcements just like a classified ad.
Who really cares ????? Nobody !!!!
I guess the answer is a respected national publication!