CHICAGO TRIBUNE DUMPS ‘JOURNATIC’

JohnLandsberg
July 16th, 2012
Journatic

     Who didn’t see this coming?
     Outsourcing items for the All-Star game and for the Olympic team have become commonplace.
     How about firing American journalists and replacing them with writers in a foreign country to handle community news? This had disaster written all over it.
    Now the Chicago Tribune on Friday night said it has suspended its use of content provider “Journatic” to produce editorial material for its suburban TribLocal publications after the discovery of plagiarized and fabricated elements in a story published this week.
    Founded in 2006, Journatic, a Chicago-based company had come under scrutiny since the public radio program This American Life reported two weeks ago that it was using low-paid writers overseas to produce items under fake bylines that were published in print and online by several major U.S. newspapers.  Journatic provides editorial content for a number of newspaper groups including the Houston Chronicle, the Chicago Sun-Times and the San Francisco Chronicle.
     It appears that the McClatchy-owned Kansas City Star has not outsourced its journalism to another country.  However, it has been reported previously that some display advertising work has been outsourced to India.   
     Journatic and its founder and CEO, Brian Timpone, have been criticized by news media observers for relying on “offshore” editorial staffers in the Philippines who are paid a fraction of what journalists in the U.S. make. Timpone has countered that the Philippine workers only did data research, and that the writing and editing was done by higher-paid staff in the U.S.
    The use of aliases, also considered a violation of the Tribune’s editorial ethics policy, prompted an internal investigation by the newspaper. Gerould Kern, the Tribune’s senior vice president and editor, said in a note to staff that the investigation is not yet compete.
    “These are the most egregious sins in journalism,” said Kern. “We do not tolerate these acts at the Chicago Tribune under any circumstances, whether from a staff member or an outside supplier like Journatic.”
    The newspaper’s parent, Tribune Co., this spring made an investment of an undisclosed amount in Chicago-based Journatic, which provides coverage for all of TribLocal’s 90 town websites and 22 weekly print editions. TribLocal is part of the Chicago Tribune Media Group’s Targeted Media division.
     It is now being reported that Journatic’s editorial chief has resigned.

3 Responses

  1. Melissa Bower says:

    I was also happy to hear that my company, GateHouse Media, is ending its relationship with Journatic. While it’s rather commonplace to share news stories within the company through a news service or outside the company through the Associated Press or Reuters, Americans have come to expect some amount of local credibility from their news sources. In many cases, that credibility is the sole pillar upon which news companies build their advertising base. Some companies find that they can save money by outsourcing publishing, distribution or design of the newspaper, but the journalism itself needs to be done through established channels to maintain credibility. http://www.poynter.org/latest-news/mediawire/180888/chicago-tribune-stops-using-journatic/

  2. Rick Nichols says:

    GateHouse’s critics point out that this company is in the process of consolidating some of its design operations at the expense of any number of local jobs. And the mere thought of The Star outsourcing some of its advertising work to India is just plain repulsive.

  3. Scott Simon says:

    Journatic is a joke. Timpone did some work around soutnern Illinois and most people I know who work in the region thought he was a clown.

Leave a Reply